Dump protective measures - wait for huge outbreak | Dr Rawiri Taonui

By Contributor

By Māori Covid-19 analyst Dr Rawiri Taonui, in partnership with Te Ao Māori News.


If the government announces tomorrow that it will do away with all the protective measures comprising vaccine passes, mandates, scanning and masks, we will see a huge and costly outbreak.

Opening the borders without sufficient controls guarantees Covid-19 has ready access to vulnerable communities.

Like much of the rest of the world, New Zealand is making decisions to live with Covid-19. Opening the schools in February was a mistake that allowed Omicron to spread via schoolchildren to families across the country.

The largest risk occurs if we let our guard down. One way we can think about the current outbreak is that Omicron accessed the most susceptible parts of our community. With a few hundred cases per day during the coming months, if we let our guard down, Omicron will gain access to the next layer of vulnerable parts of the community.

The less vaccinated Māori and Pacific communities, always working from the back foot, have made tremendous efforts getting whānau tested in mid-2020, pushing vaccinations despite a poorly designed rollout and pushing back against Delta and Omicron. We must be concerned about how many times our communities can repeat that effort and what happens if the walls come down.

Auckland peak

Cases in the Omicron outbreak first began surging in Auckland Metro (Waitematā, Auckland and Manukau), the Waikato, Bay of Plenty and Lakes DHBs (District Health Boards) on February 1 through a nexus of transport links between Auckland, Hamilton, Tauranga, and Rotorua.

Case numbers grew exponentially after the introduction of Rapid Antigen Tests (RATs) on February 24. Metro Auckland reached its peak on March 3 with 13,237 new cases. The Waikato (2,146 cases), Bay of Plenty (1,691) and the Lakes (660) peaked simultaneously on March 8. Post-peak spikes and troughs continue to trend downward.

North Island Provincial DHBs

Cases in other DHBs began surging 12 days after Auckland. All 20 DHBs in the country registered new cases for the first time on February 13.

The trajectory of Omicron cases in the provincial North Island continued the 12-day Auckland-centred pattern with all DHBs peaking between March 15 to 17.

The Hawkes Bay (1,111), Mid-Central (888), Whanganui (276), Te Tai Rāwhiti (446), and  Capital & Coast (1,584) DHBs peaked on March 15, the Taranaki DHB (663) one day later, March 16, and the Wairārapa DHD (260) two days later on March 17.

The two exceptions to the pattern, the Hutt Valley DHB (1,103) which peaked earlier on March 10 and Northland (765), possibly because of its proximity and highway to Auckland, peaked on March 11. The pattern of spikes and troughs continues a slow downward trajectory.

South Island provincial DHBs

South Island provincial DHBs followed the same pattern. The Nelson (524), South Canterbury (217) and Southern (1,238) DHBs also peaked 12 days after Auckland metro on March 15, and the West Coast (60) two days later on March 17. Canterbury (2,694) peaked two days later on March 19.

The pattern of steadily declining peaks and troughs in the South is slower than in the North Island.

While Canterbury appeared to peak on March 19, cases have been running at a steady 2,140 per day for 14 days, which risks a further surge. Cases have been declining in the Southern DHB but with new cases at more than 1,050 per day for most of the last week, there are also risks around the Dunedin area.

Cases by ethnicity

Omicron has significantly impacted the Pākehā community. Pākehā have had the highest number of new cases of all ethnicities for the past 27 days in a row. Covid-19 has shown that the Pākehā community travels more than other communities, something Omicron has exploited to its advantage. While numbers are trending off-peak, they remain high and more risk-volatile relative to other groups.

Cases were the highest or second-highest in the Asian community during three weeks between January 25 and February 14, in part because of their high percentage Auckland population. Our highest vaccinated ethnicity, the Asian community, has successfully pushed back. Numbers are steadily declining.

Omicron hit the Pacific peoples community in early February because of lower than national level vaccinations, comorbidities like Māori, more prevalent crowded housing, and the concentration of population in Auckland. Pacific peoples were the highest or second-highest daily cases every day between February 5 and March 5. The Pacific peoples community initiated a strong response that saw a remarkable and early decline in new cases compared to other communities.

Coming off the back of a massive holiday period Māori response, which saw new Māori cases during the tail of the Delta outbreak fall to a low of just three cases on February 1, Māoridom’s overall lower vaccination rates allowed Omicron cases to build through February. Māori have had the second-highest daily cases for the past 16 days. Numbers are trending down but remain higher than for the Pacific and Asian communities.

The long tail

The largest proportional decline in cases has come in the Pacific Peoples, Asian and Māori communities. Continuing higher rates among the Pākehā community, and in Christchurch and Dunedin are a concern. Coupled with an approximate 75% slower decline in overall daily cases, when compared to the original increase, Omicron will have a long tail lasting between one and three months.

Other countries

Over the past week, countries in Western and Eastern Europe, and in Asia where Omicron peaked in January/February, are seeing new surges of Omicron, including Britain, Australia, Russia, China and Hong Kong.

BA.2

There are risks of surges. One is from the Omicron BA.2  sub-variant. BA.2 is more transmissible than the BA.1 sub-variant, which has driven cases over the last month. Earlier in the worldwide Omicron outbreak, some countries saw large secondary BA.2 surges. More recent surges have been smaller and slower, the research suggesting that recovery from BA.1 confers additional immunity against BA.2.

Waning protection from third booster

The waning of third booster shots may also become a factor in the Omicron tail. Current research shows that the third booster gives significantly greater protection against severe disease and hospitalisation than a single or double dose of the Pfizer vaccine and for a longer three-to-six-month period. Beyond that lies unfamiliar territory. Of additional concern, efforts to manufacture an Omicron-specific vaccination have also stalled.

New variants

There are also risks of another variant emerging. Health authorities are monitoring what they term Deltacron variants, a collection of variants with Delta and Omicron traits.

The World Health Organisation is monitoring a recombinant of Delta and Omicron BA.1xAY.4. First identified in France, the variant has been circulating across Europe since early January 2022. The European Centre for Disease Prevention and Control is monitoring another circulating recombinant, V1.2.133 (AY.4.2.2/- BA.1), first detected in Britain on January 7.

Whether any of these or other variants emerge as threats remains moot. They do not appear to be growing exponentially. Nevertheless, Covid-19 has taught us that new variants will drive new outbreaks if there is inequality in vaccinations between rich and poor countries and between the affluent and poor in western countries.

Kia noho haumaru i runga I tō rangatiratanga. Say safe and self-sovereign.

Dr Rawiri Taonui.